LoafScout

Guides Starter problems

Starter problems, sorted

Most strange starter behavior is harmless, and a few signs mean the jar has to go, with no exceptions. Start with the starter that will not rise, then find the smell, the liquid or the color you are looking at.

New here? Read Sourdough Starter Not Rising: Every Cause and Fix first. A sluggish starter is almost always too cool, too young or underfed, and that guide walks through each cause in the order worth checking. The rest of this section takes one symptom at a time: the liquid on top, the smells, a runny jar, a starter that rises and falls before you can use it, and the colors that mean it is over.

Throw it out, or feed it?

Two lists settle most worries. Find what you see or smell in the jar:

What you see or smell What it is What to do
Gray, brown or black liquid on top Hooch, from a hungry starter Pour it off or stir it in, then feed
A flat, smooth, dry skin, nothing fuzzy A poorly covered jar Remove it, feed from the soft starter underneath
A nail polish or acetone smell A hungry starter Feed, a little more often
A quiet few days, around days 3 to 7 A young starter settling Keep feeding
Fuzzy or raised spots of any color, on the starter or the glass Mold Start fresh: discard the whole starter
Pink, orange or red streaks, patches or tinted liquid Spoilage Start fresh: discard the whole starter
A rotten, putrid smell, or slime that will not stir back in Spoilage Discard, even if it looks fine

If you cannot tell a dry skin from mold, treat it as mold. A new starter costs a little flour and a week or two.

Why is my sourdough starter not rising?

Check these in order, and change one thing at a time:

  1. Temperature. A slow starter likes a warm spot around 75 to 80F (24 to 27C). In a cold kitchen, that alone can be the whole answer.
  2. Age. A new starter usually takes 7 to 14 days to become reliable, sometimes longer in a cool kitchen. Under 14 days, it is still young.
  3. Feeding. Keep only 20 to 50 g, discard before each feed, and make sure the jar is no more than a third full after feeding. A little whole wheat or rye brings more food to a sluggish jar.
  4. Timing. It may have risen and fallen while you were not looking. A tide line on the glass above the starter means it peaked and fell, which is Past its peak, not a dead starter.

Where to start

Try it

Most slow starters are on the wrong ratio for their room. The starter feeding calculator shows the usual hours to peak for each ratio in a cool, average or warm kitchen.

Heads up

Food safety wins every time. If anything in the jar is fuzzy, pink or orange, discard the whole starter, do not scrape off the spot, and wash the jar in hot, soapy water before you begin again. When in doubt, throw it out.

Guides in this section