Troubleshooting
Fix my loaf
Something went wrong and you want to know what. Find the symptom, read the cause, change one thing. Every guide here ends with the lever to move next bake, or with when a starter needs to start again.
Start with the symptom that bothers you most. A loaf usually has one main fault and a few smaller notes, and fixing the main one often takes care of the rest.
A loaf that went wrong
- Dense, gummy or heavy: why is my sourdough dense and gummy. First check you waited at least 1 to 2 hours before cutting.
- Flat, or spreading out instead of up: why is my sourdough flat. Flat and pale usually means too far; flat and tight means not far enough.
- Big holes, tunnels or a gap under the crust: big holes in sourdough and the sourdough crumb, read it like a baker.
- Not sure if it was under or over: underproofed vs overproofed, and the sourdough poke test to check the next dough before it goes in.
- No ear, or the score did not open: how to get an ear on sourdough.
- Everything is slow in a cold kitchen: sourdough in winter.
A starter that worries you
- It will not rise, or barely doubles: sourdough starter not rising. It is almost always too cool, too young or underfed.
- It peaks too early or too late: starter feeding ratios shows how a bigger or smaller feed moves the peak.
- Liquid on top: hooch on sourdough starter. Gray, brown or black liquid is a hungry starter, not spoilage.
- Fuzz, spots, or pink or orange color: sourdough starter mold. The whole jar goes.
Then change one thing. If you change bulk, water and the bake at once, the next loaf cannot tell you which one helped. Most home bakers, especially early on, underproof more often than they overproof, so if you are unsure, a longer bulk is the safer first try.
Try it
Answer seven questions about the cut loaf in the crumb troubleshooter for a proof call and the one lever to change. For a slow or fast starter, the starter feeding calculator shows how ratio and room temperature move the peak.
Heads up
Fuzzy mold of any color, or pink, orange or red streaks in the jar, cannot be fixed. Discard the whole starter, do not scrape it, wash the jar in hot, soapy water and start fresh with how to make a sourdough starter. A rotten smell or a slimy texture that will not stir back in means the same.
Browse by topic
- Starter care guides
- Starter problems, sorted
- Reading the crumb
- Bulk and proofing guides
- Hydration and flour guides
- Schedules and seasons
- Loaf troubleshooting
- Shaping, scoring and baking
Guides for fixing a loaf or a starter

Reading the crumb
The Sourdough Crumb: Read It Like a Baker

Bulk and proofing
Underproofed vs Overproofed Sourdough: How to Tell

Starter problems
Sourdough Starter Not Rising: Every Cause and Fix

Bulk and proofing
How Long to Bulk Ferment Sourdough

Loaf troubleshooting
Why Is My Sourdough Dense and Gummy?

Starter care
How to Tell When Your Starter Is Ready to Bake

Schedules and seasons
The Cold Proof: An Overnight Sourdough Schedule

Starter problems
Hooch on Sourdough Starter: What the Liquid Means

Loaf troubleshooting
Why Is My Sourdough Flat? Spreading Loaves, Explained

Reading the crumb
Big Holes in Sourdough: Good Sign or Fault?

Starter problems
Sourdough Starter Mold: What It Looks Like, What to Do

Bulk and proofing
The Sourdough Poke Test, and When Not to Trust It

Schedules and seasons
Sourdough in Winter: Keeping a Cold Kitchen Moving

Shaping, scoring and baking
How to Get an Ear on Sourdough


Reading the crumb
Fool's Crumb: The Gap Under the Crust

Starter problems
Starter Smells Like Nail Polish or Acetone? Read This

Hydration and flour
High Hydration Sourdough: When It Helps and When It Hurts

Shaping, scoring and baking
Baking Sourdough in a Dutch Oven: Heat, Lid and Timing

Bulk and proofing
How Long to Proof Sourdough After Shaping