Guides Reading the crumb
Reading the crumb
A cut loaf is a record of everything the dough went through. Start with the full guide to reading a slice, then go deep on the patterns people ask about most: big holes, tunnels, the gap under the crust and a dense base.
New here? Read The Sourdough Crumb: Read It Like a Baker first. It is the one page that covers the whole slice, from the outline to the base, and why the question that matters most is not how big the holes are but how even they are from top to bottom. The rest of this section takes one pattern at a time.
The rule that saves the most confusion: big holes alone do not tell you anything. Big holes in a tight, heavy crumb point to underproofing. Big ragged holes in a weak, sagging loaf point to overproofing. An even crumb with holes of many sizes is good bread, whether it is open or tight, and whole wheat, rye and spelt bake tighter by nature.
What is your sourdough crumb telling you?
Find the row that looks most like your slice. Each pattern points at one lever, the one step to change next bake. Leave everything else the same.
| What you see | Often means | Lever |
|---|---|---|
| Even holes of many sizes, thin glossy walls | Well proofed | Keep it: write down bulk time and dough temperature |
| Big tunnels in tight, heavy crumb | Underfermented | Bulk: 1 to 2 hours longer |
| Wide gap under the top crust, denser below | Fool's crumb, usually underproofed | Bulk |
| Tight, compact band at the base | Underfermented; a pot not fully preheated adds to it | Bulk |
| Big ragged holes, thin torn walls, sunken top | Overfermented | Bulk: end it sooner |
| Wet, shiny, sticks to the knife | Cut while hot, most often | Cooling: wait at least 1 to 2 hours |
| Small, even, close-set holes | Lower hydration or more fermentation needed; normal for whole grain | Hydration |
| A spiral, seam or pale streak | Folds that did not seal; cosmetic | Shaping |
If the slice fits the first row, the verdict is Bake it again. If one row explains most of what you see, it is One change next bake: move that lever and nothing else.
Where to start
- Your first cut loaf: the sourdough crumb, read it like a baker walks the slice from top to bottom.
- The holes look huge: big holes in sourdough sorts holes that are a fault from holes that are just good bread, and the pockets that shaping folds in.
- Not sure if it was under or over: underproofed vs overproofed reads the crumb around the holes, the shape and the crust together.
- Wet, heavy or gummy: why is my sourdough dense and gummy separates a loaf cut too soon from one that never built enough gas.
A photo can mislead. Light, angle and a warm knife all change how a crumb looks, so read the slice in daylight, straight on, once it is fully cool.
Try it
Answer seven questions about your slice in the crumb troubleshooter and get a proof call, the faults that fit, and the one lever to change next bake.
Good to know
Cut only when the loaf is fully cool, straight through the middle, and look in daylight. A loaf cut warm looks gummier and denser than it really is.
Related topics
- Bulk and proofing guides: the fermentation behind almost every crumb pattern.
- Loaf troubleshooting: dense, gummy, flat and pale loaves, one fault at a time.
- Hydration and flour guides: why a wetter dough or a whole grain flour changes the crumb.
Guides in this section

Reading the crumb
The Sourdough Crumb: Read It Like a Baker

Reading the crumb
Big Holes in Sourdough: Good Sign or Fault?

Reading the crumb
Fool's Crumb: The Gap Under the Crust