LoafScout

Guides Bulk and proofing

Bulk and proofing guides

Most of a sourdough loaf is decided before it meets the oven. Start with how to tell underproofed from overproofed and how long to bulk ferment, then go deep on the rise, temperature and the poke test.

New here? Start with two guides. Underproofed vs Overproofed Sourdough: How to Tell reads the finished loaf back to the fermentation that made it. How Long to Bulk Ferment Sourdough works forward: what the dough should look like when bulk is done, and why the clock on the recipe rarely matches your kitchen.

The short version: temperature sets the pace, so read the dough, not the clock. Bulk is usually done when the dough has grown roughly 50 to 75 percent, has domed edges and bubbles, and jiggles when you shake the bowl. The poke test belongs to the final proof, not bulk. And if you are unsure which way to adjust, most home bakers underproof far more often than they overproof.

How long does bulk fermentation take?

Bulk fermentation is the first rise, from mixing to shaping. Its length depends mostly on the dough's temperature, which is why no single time is right for every kitchen.

Dough temperature Bulk often takes What to do
About 78F (26C) About 4 to 5 hours Check the dough early
74 to 76F (23 to 24C) 2 to 5 hours, with more starter in the dough Watch for the signs, not the clock
About 68F (20C) 8 hours or more Warm water at the mix, a warmer spot

Bulk is done when the signs line up: grown roughly 50 to 75 percent (doubled is usually too far), domed edges, bubbles on top and through the sides, and a jiggle like set gelatin. Any one alone can mislead. A straight-sided container with the start level marked makes the rise easy to read.

Underproofed or overproofed?

Sign Underproofed Overproofed
Shape and crust Often a blowout along the score or side Flat and spread, pale crust, no ear
Dough before the oven A poke springs right back A poke does not spring back; sticks to the banneton, smells sharp and boozy
Crumb Tunnels in tight, heavy crumb; a dense band at the base; a gap under the top crust Collapsed, lacy crumb with thin torn walls
Next bake Extend bulk 1 to 2 hours End bulk 1 to 2 hours sooner, or bulk cooler around 72F (22C)

Both can show big holes. Read the crumb around them, as underproofed vs overproofed explains.

The poke test, and where it fits

The sourdough poke test is for the shaped dough at the end of the final proof. Flour a fingertip and press about 1/2 inch (1 cm) in. It springs right back: give it more time. It fills back slowly and leaves a small dimple: bake. It does not spring back at all: likely overproofed, bake now. Cold dough from the fridge always springs back more slowly, so trust the test less after a cold proof.

Try it

Not sure which way your last loaf went? The crumb troubleshooter turns seven questions about the slice into a proof call and the one change to make.

Guides in this section