Big Holes in Sourdough: Good Sign or Fault?

You cut the loaf and there it is: a hole you could fit a thumb in, maybe two. It looks dramatic, and you are not sure whether to be proud of it or worried. The hole on its own will not tell you. The crumb around it will.
Quick answer
Big holes in sourdough are good when they sit in an even crumb with holes of many sizes from top to bottom. A few big holes or tunnels in tight, heavy crumb usually mean underproofing or air folded in while shaping. Ragged holes in a flat, pale, lacy loaf point to overproofing instead.
The read
A few big holes surrounded by tight, dense crumb, often with a heavier band at the base, means the dough was underfermented. Extend bulk by 1 to 2 hours, until the dough has grown about 50 percent, looks domed and jiggles, and leave everything else the same. If the next loaf comes out flat, pale and lacy, you went past it.
Key takeaways
- Judge the crumb around the holes, not the holes themselves.
- Big holes in strong, tight crumb point to underproofing. Big ragged holes in weak, sagging crumb point to overproofing.
- A gap right under the top crust with denser crumb below is fool's crumb, usually underproofing.
- Pockets of air folded in during shaping make big holes too. Shape with gentle, even tension.
- Tall, even and well browned with a few larger holes is probably just good bread.
Sourdough has big holes: is that good or bad?
An open crumb is not automatically a good one, and a tight one is not a fault. What you want is consistency: cells of many sizes spread through the whole slice, with thin, slightly glossy walls and a crumb that springs back when you press it.
So the question is not how big the holes are, but how even they are from top to bottom, and what the rest of the loaf looks like. A few large holes in an even, airy crumb are a good sign. A few large holes in a crumb that is tight everywhere else are the opposite. The sourdough crumb guide walks through every pattern on the cut face.
Big holes in the crumb: what each pattern means
Look at where the holes sit, what their walls look like, and how the loaf behaved. Then match the slice to a row.
| What you see | Most likely cause | Lever | The one change |
|---|---|---|---|
| Holes of many sizes, even top to bottom, thin glossy walls, tall loaf | Well fermented | keep | Bake it again and write down what you did |
| A few big tunnels in tight, heavy crumb, dense at the base | Underfermented | bulk | Extend bulk by 1 to 2 hours, until about 50% risen, domed and jiggly |
| A wide gap under the top crust, denser crumb below | Underproofed (fool's crumb) | bulk | Longer bulk, light shaping flour, poke test before baking |
| One or two odd pockets in otherwise even crumb | Air folded in while shaping | shaping | Gentle, even tension; degas lightly before shaping |
| Ragged holes, thin torn walls, flat pale loaf | Overfermented | bulk | End bulk 1 to 2 hours sooner, or bulk cooler, around 72F (22C) |
Try it
Answer seven questions about your cut loaf in the crumb troubleshooter and get the proof call, the faults that fit, and the one lever to move next bake.
Why both underproofed and overproofed bread can show big holes
Both edges of the proof scale can leave big holes, for different reasons.
In an underproofed loaf, the gas was never spread evenly through the dough. When it meets the heat, steam and gas force their way through the weakest spots and blow out a few big channels instead of many small cells. The crumb around them stays tight, heavy and often a little gummy. The loaf is often tall, with a wild burst along the score or the side.
In an overproofed loaf, the walls between bubbles were stretched so thin that they tore and merged, leaving ragged holes in a crumb that looks deflated. The loaf is usually flat and pale, with little or no ear. One is big holes in a strong, tight crumb. The other is big holes in a weak, sagging one. Underproofed vs overproofed lays out every sign side by side.

Sourdough big holes but dense
This is the most common pattern home bakers ask about: a few big holes or tunnels, often near the top or center, and tight, closed crumb everywhere else. Sometimes there is a dense band along the bottom too.
It is classic underfermentation. Cool kitchens, young starters and recipe times written for warmer rooms all make it more likely, and home bakers land on this side far more often than the other. If you are unsure, lean toward a longer bulk.
The fix is time in bulk. Extend it by 1 to 2 hours, until the dough has grown about 50 percent, looks domed and jiggles when you shake the bowl. If your kitchen is cool, bulk somewhere warmer, around 76 to 78F (24 to 26C). A dough that finishes bulk in about 4 to 5 hours at 78F (26C) can take 8 hours or more at 68F (20C). Sourdough tunnels goes deeper into this one pattern.
Sourdough big holes and gummy
Gummy crumb around big holes usually comes from the same place: underfermentation. Heavy, moist crumb that stays that way once cool sits at the underproofed end of the scale.
Rule out the knife first, though. A loaf cut while still warm squashes the half-set crumb into a wet, gummy layer, and that makes any underproofing look worse than it is. Wait at least 1 to 2 hours before cutting a regular loaf, longer for a large one, and bake until the center reads about 205 to 210F (96 to 99C). If it is still gummy and full of tunnels once fully cool and baked through, extend bulk. Dense and gummy sourdough covers the order to check in.
Heads up
Lower the dough into a preheated pot on a parchment sling, wear oven mitts, and lift the lid away from your face. The steam that gives a loaf its spring can burn.
Sourdough big holes at the top
A wide gap just under the top crust, as if the crust lifted away from the crumb, with denser crumb below it, is often called fool's crumb. It looks open at a glance, but it is usually a sign of underproofing. The top set in the oven while the gassy center kept pushing up and pulled away from it.
Too much flour on the surface during shaping can add to it, because the layers cannot seal. The fix: extend bulk until the dough is airy and domed, use only a light dusting of flour when shaping, and proof until a floured poke fills back slowly instead of springing right back.
There is one exception worth knowing. An overproofed loaf can also show a large hole up near the crust. Tell them apart by the rest of the loaf: a tall loaf with a burst score and tight crumb at the base points to under; a flat, pale loaf with lacy, torn crumb points to over. Fool's crumb covers the gap under the crust in full.
Big holes from shaping
Not every big hole comes from fermentation. One or two odd pockets in an otherwise even crumb are often air folded into the dough while shaping. Loose, uneven shaping traps a bubble between layers, and the oven inflates it.
Shape with gentle, even tension all the way around, and do not fold over big pockets of air. A gentle degas as you shape helps spread the gas through the dough, so the holes even out. Press too hard, though, and you lose the open crumb you worked for: the big bubbles break into smaller ones and the crumb turns tight and uniform.
Add-ins leave their own gaps. Seeds, nuts and fruit cut through the gluten and leave small pockets around them, so read the dough between them, not the gaps.

When big holes are a win
If the loaf is tall, well browned and bloomed cleanly at the score, and the holes are many sizes, spread evenly, with thin, glossy walls, you have a well fermented loaf. A higher hydration dough makes an open crumb easier to reach, but water is only a helper: the open crumb people chase comes mostly from good fermentation and shaping.
A tight, even crumb is a style too, not a fault; whole wheat, rye and spelt bake tighter by nature. Every other pattern on the cut face is in the guides on reading the crumb.
Tip
Light, angle and a warm knife all change how a crumb looks. Cut a cool loaf straight down through the middle with a serrated knife, and look at the slice in daylight before you decide what the holes mean.
What to do today
- Wait until the loaf feels barely warm or cool before you cut it.
- Cut straight down through the middle and look at the whole slice, top crust to base.
- Note the loaf's height, the score and the crust color.
- Press the crumb next to the biggest hole: springy and light, or tight, heavy and moist?
- Take one straight-on photo of the crumb in daylight, and write down bulk time and dough temperature.
- Change one thing next bake.
What to change next bake
- Big tunnels in tight, heavy crumb, dense at the base: bulk, 1 to 2 hours longer, until about 50 percent risen, domed and jiggly.
- Gap under the top crust, denser crumb below: bulk, longer, and a lighter dusting of shaping flour.
- Big holes and gummy, even when fully cool: bulk. If it was cut warm, cooling first: wait 1 to 2 hours.
- One or two odd pockets in even crumb: shaping. Gentle, even tension, no big folds of air.
- Ragged holes, torn walls, flat and pale loaf: bulk, 1 to 2 hours sooner, or bulk cooler around 72F (22C).
- Tall, well browned, holes of many sizes from top to bottom: Bake it again, and write down what you did so you can repeat it.
A big hole is a question, not a verdict. Read the crumb around it, the height of the loaf and the color of the crust, then pick the one lever that fits and leave the rest alone for one bake.
The pictures in this guide are AI-generated illustrations, not photos of real bakes; real loaves and starters vary, so trust the signs described in the text over any picture. Loaf Scout guides are general baking guidance, written from the sources named below, and every kitchen, flour and oven is a little different. Loaf Scout gives an AI read of one photo; your own eyes, nose and the poke test still count. A starter with fuzzy mold of any color, pink or orange streaks, or a rotten smell is thrown out and started again, whatever any page says.
Questions people ask
Are big holes in sourdough good?
Only when they sit in an even crumb. Holes of many sizes spread from top to bottom, with thin, glossy walls, in a tall, well browned loaf, mean good fermentation. A few big holes in tight, heavy crumb mean the dough needed more time.
Why does my sourdough have big holes but a dense crumb?
A few big holes or tunnels in a tight, heavy crumb usually mean the dough was underfermented, so the oven blew a few channels instead of many small cells. Extend bulk by 1 to 2 hours next bake.
Why is there a big hole at the top of my sourdough?
A gap just under the top crust with denser crumb below is usually fool's crumb, a sign of underproofing; too much shaping flour can add to it. In a flat, pale, lacy loaf, a hole near the top points to overproofing instead.
Why is my sourdough full of holes and gummy?
Gummy crumb around big holes is usually underfermentation, and cutting the loaf while warm makes it look worse. Wait at least 1 to 2 hours before cutting, and if it is still gummy once cool, extend bulk.
How do I get fewer big holes in sourdough?
Give bulk enough time for the gas to spread through the whole dough, then shape with gentle, even tension so you do not fold in big pockets of air. A gentle degas before final shaping helps even the holes out.
Sources
- The Perfect Loaf: The ultimate guide to proofing bread dough: www.theperfectloaf.com/guides/proofing-bread-dough/
- The Perfect Loaf: How to bake open crumb sourdough bread: www.theperfectloaf.com/how-to-bake-open-crumb-sourdough-bread/
- The Perfect Loaf: The ultimate guide to bread dough bulk fermentation: www.theperfectloaf.com/guides/the-ultimate-guide-to-bread-dough-bulk-fermentatio
- The Perfect Loaf: The ultimate guide to baking bread dough: www.theperfectloaf.com/guides/the-ultimate-guide-to-baking-bread-dough/
Read next

Reading the crumb
The Sourdough Crumb: Read It Like a Baker

Reading the crumb
Fool's Crumb: The Gap Under the Crust

Hydration and flour
High Hydration Sourdough: When It Helps and When It Hurts

Starter care
How to Tell When Your Starter Is Ready to Bake

Shaping, scoring and baking
Baking Sourdough in a Dutch Oven: Heat, Lid and Timing

Starter problems
Sourdough Starter Mold: What It Looks Like, What to Do